How To Video Game

Crusader Kings 3 Silk and Silver: How Trade Goods Work

A robed merchant lets gold coins fall between his hands beside a table holding an oil jug, a wine goblet, grapes, a book and an ivory elephant, as a camel caravan crosses the desert behind him, in official Silk and Silver art

In Silk and Silver, trade goods are made by the resource districts and buildings in each county, pooled in the Market of their de jure duchy, and used first by the buildings in that Market. Whatever is left over is surplus that trade routes carry to Markets with a deficit, where it fills the needs of buildings that grant their bonuses only while they are supplied.

That one loop drives the whole expansion. Landed rulers use it to keep their buildings and holdings fed, while Merchants and Republics make their gold buying surplus cheap and selling it where it is needed. The numbers below are the base values from Paradox’s pre-release dev diaries for Crusader Kings III, and Paradox said nearly all of them were still being balanced, so expect some to differ in the launch version.

Every Trade Good in Silk and Silver

Paradox’s October 27 dev diary puts it at 44 trade goods in 20 need categories. Each good belongs to exactly one category, and buildings usually ask for a category rather than a single good: a building that needs Cereals takes grain, rice or millet. Sixteen goods are Basic Goods, the everyday supplies that Distribution Routes carry automatically.

Category Goods Basic Goods?
Cereals Grain, Rice, Millet Yes
Meats Cured Meat, Fish Yes
Alcohol Wine, Beer Yes
Beasts of Burden Horses, Cattle Yes
Carpentries Wood, Hemp Yes
Stone Stone Yes
Base Metals Iron, Copper Yes
Precious Metals Gold, Silver Yes
Comforts Cheese, Fruit, Oil, Honey, Tea No
Salt Salt No
Fabric Wool, Cotton, Flax No
Clothes Textiles, Furs, Leather No
Dyes Dyes No
Alum Alum No
Luxury Items Ceramics, Glass, Jewelry, Lacquerware, Silk No
Precious Stones Gems, Amber, Ivory, Jade No
Luxury Consumables Sugar, Spices No
Medicaments Medicaments No
Incense Incense No
Books Books No

The goods come from the full list in Paradox’s September 1 dev diary, which names 45. The October diary and the November 10 diary, which shows an icon for every good, both count 44, so one of the September goods was merged or cut before launch.

There are also 16 wider groupings, such as Luxury, Staple Goods and Forest Goods, that buildings cannot ask for but modifiers can target. One Luxury sell price modifier, for example, raises the price of all 11 luxury goods at once.

Where Trade Goods Come From

Resource districts. Every county capital has a resource district, and nearly all of them are built around one main good. The district’s owner collects the taxes, and the Market receives the goods. Which goods a county can make is fixed by its potential: wood can be produced in 2,276 counties, jade in only 8. Each county has a list of 3 to 5 potential goods, so you can switch its resource district to another one, but switching destroys the buildings inside it. You can also use the district’s building slots to make a small amount of a potential good you are not otherwise producing. Mining districts are the one exception to the one-good rule: a mine produces every minable good the county has potential for.

Production math. Each barony works out its output every month. Paradox’s worked example: a tier 1 grain farm makes 60 grain, farmlands terrain (+100%) takes that to 120, and the Heavy Plow innovation plus the farm’s iron need being met (+15%) brings it to 129. Multipliers can never push production below 10%.

Goods made from other goods. Nine goods have no county potential anywhere on the map: cheese, cured meat, beer, textiles, leather, glass, jewelry, lacquerware and books. They only come from buildings that convert other goods. Feed a Weavers’ Guild 30 Fabric, for example, and it produces 10 Textiles. Resource districts can do some of this too (grain can become beer), and the Guild District exists for it: it makes nothing until its needs are filled, then turns raw materials into pricier goods and pays artisan taxes.

What Buildings Do With Trade Goods

Needs come from buildings, and there are nearly 4,500 need definitions across the game. A need asks for a good or a category in a set amount, and many can be filled more than once, paying their reward each time. Paradox’s early examples: a fishing hut produces more fish when it is supplied with salt, and a port pays more taxes when it gets wood for its ships.

An unmet need costs you the bonus, nothing more. The trade system itself never punishes a building that goes without. The exception is food. Holdings need food in proportion to their settlement size, and a holding that cannot get enough from its Market loses settlement size baseline and popular opinion until its people are fed. Castles turn their met food needs into Food Supply. What counts as food can depend on faith: a Jain holding, for example, needs Comforts in place of Meat.

Who eats first. When a Market runs short, needs are filled in this order:

  1. The county that holds the Market Capital: the Market Capital barony, then the county capital, then its other baronies by settlement size.
  2. The other counties in the Market, ordered by the settlement size of their capitals.
  3. Inside a holding: the holding district, then the resource, trade post and entrepôt districts and other special districts, then your regular districts in the order you set.
  4. Inside a district: its buildings, in the order you set.

The last two steps are yours to control. If your Weavers’ Guild matters more than your tavern, move it up the list.

How Markets Work

There are 922 Markets, one for every de jure duchy with at least one county. Each sits in a Market Capital, normally the capital barony of the duchy’s capital county. Paradox moved 54 of them, mostly to put their Market on the coast: Aquitaine, for example, trades from La Rochelle. Markets are fixed for the whole game, and a county that drifts to another de jure duchy keeps its baronies in its original Market. Loading a save from before Silk and Silver creates the Markets on load.

The Market Owner is whoever holds the county the Market Capital barony sits in. That ruler sets tolls, grants monopolies and can commission merchants.

Each month a Market adds up its production and needs, feeds its own buildings, and works out its surplus (production left after local needs) and deficit (needs left unmet). Those two numbers are what trade works with. Markets and routes each do their monthly work on their own day, spread across 30 daily buckets, so up to a month can pass between a route selling a good and the destination’s buildings getting it.

Prices: Prosperity, Not Supply and Demand

Every good has a base price, and two things move it most: Prosperity and modifiers.

Market Prosperity Sell price Buy price
100 +50% Base
50 +25% Base
0 Base -15%

The sell price rises 0.5% for every point of average Prosperity, up to +50% at 100. The buy price stays flat at 50 Prosperity or above, then drops 0.3% for every point below 50, down to -15% at 0. In short, buy in struggling Markets and sell in thriving ones.

Scarcity does not change prices. Paradox tried it early in development and dropped it: in the diary’s words, “scarcity only decides how much you can trade, not what it costs.” Modifiers do the rest. Every castle past its first level adds +1% to the Cereals sell price in its Market, grain farms raise iron’s, plains make grain cheaper to buy, and the Market District raises the price merchants get for selling in that Market, which is how a ruler with a hungry Guild District attracts sellers.

Early trade is small money. Paradox’s own cured meat example works out to about 0.41 gold a month on a route with the base 30 capacity, and the gold grows as your capacity, expertise and Competitiveness do.

The Three Kinds of Trade Route

No government gets both main route types. Feudal, Clan, Tribal and Administrative rulers run Distribution Routes, and Merchants and Republics run Profit Routes.

Profit Route Distribution Route Commission Route
Who Merchants and Republic patricians Dukes and above (1 for a duke, 2 for a king, 3 for an emperor, 4 for a hegemon) A landed patron hires one of their merchant clients
Markets Up to 3, one of them a home Market Exactly 2, both owned by you or a vassal One of the patron’s Markets
Goods Up to 6, you choose Every Basic Good the two Markets can supply each other, chosen automatically One good
Limits 30 base capacity, 10 base route length No capacity or length limit Runs for 10 years
Earns gold? Yes, for mercantile rulers No, and pays no tolls Supplies the patron

Distribution Routes are served before any Profit Route, so a large duke’s own lands get their basic supplies first, and merchants compete for what is left. Route length is counted in baronies along roads, including seas and navigable rivers, and roads raise maximum route length by 5% at tier 1 up to 25% at tier 5. Roads grow as routes use them and decay when trade stops.

A Profit Route that breaks the rules, for example by losing its home Market, is suspended rather than deleted until you fix it. Moving your merchant company destroys every route you have, so choose your base with care.

Primary Goods, Trade Expertise and Monopolies

Primary Good. The first good on a Profit Route is its Primary Good. It gets first claim on the route’s capacity, gives the route its name (the Venetian Silk Route, say), and earns Trade Expertise in its category. Each need category has 20 expertise levels, and expertise lives on the merchant’s title, so your heir keeps it.

Competitiveness. When several routes trade the same good in a Market, each gets a share of the surplus or deficit in proportion to its Competitiveness, which starts at 10 for every ruler. Shares a route does not use pass to the routes that do, and if nobody else trades the good, your share is 100%.

Monopolies. The Market Owner can grant a monopoly on one need category or the whole Market (a Complete Monopoly) to a merchant, a Republic or a Trade League. A Normal Monopoly locks out competitors without touching prices. An Exploitative Monopoly also lets its holder buy from the Market’s total production, before local buildings are fed. Monopolies do not expire, are inherited, survive the Market changing hands, and never block Distribution Routes. The AI is reluctant to grant them, and even more so for Complete and Exploitative ones.

Several achievements are built on this system, including “In Sweden we have a System…” (max out Alcohol expertise and hold an Alcohol monopoly in your home Market), “There Can Be Only One” (seven monopolies at once) and the Silk and Silver achievement itself (max out both Luxury Items and Precious Metals expertise).

Tolls

Market Owners profit from trade through tolls, which come in six levels: None (0%), Minimal (1%), Low (2%), Medium (3%), High (4%) and Very High (5%). Every Market starts at Medium. Tolls are taken only from sales on Profit Routes, never from buying, and the Market Owner, their direct vassals and their merchant clients pay none. Toll income counts as commerce tax, so commerce tax modifiers raise it and your liege can tax it.

Changing tolls has a 36-month cooldown that belongs to you, not the Market, so you can change a Market’s tolls the day you inherit or conquer it. Steep tolls push merchants to sell elsewhere, and a merchant can ask for a Toll Exception that sets their personal rate for 10 years.

Entrepôts and Long-Distance Goods

Entrepôts are special districts in famous trade cities along the Silk Road, including Cairo, Baghdad, Constantinople and Venice. Their needs work differently: goods delivered to them are resold, so a second merchant can carry them on to Markets even further away. An entrepôt fills its needs last, after local buildings, and it only resells goods moving away from their origin. Silk, for example, comes from the east, so an entrepôt on the Silk Road resells silk arriving from the east, but not silk carried back toward it. That is what stops merchants from trading the same goods in circles between two entrepôts.

What Comes Free and What Needs the Expansion

Paradox’s first dev diary says the economy rework comes free with the patch that launches alongside Silk and Silver, because the game’s balance depends on it: districts and buildings replace the old building slots (the patch removes every regular building), and development splits into Settlement Size and Prosperity. The Silk and Silver expansion itself, $29.99 on PC, adds the Merchant and Republic governments, the two that run Profit Routes, along with Trade Leagues, Trade Posts, two new bookmarks and the Italian content, per Paradox’s launch announcement.

Because the patch replaces every regular building, any mod that edits buildings needs an update before it works again, so check your list against our best Crusader Kings 3 mods before loading an old save. Our Silk and Silver release time guide covers the unlock and pricing, our announcement story covers the reveal, and if you are coming from the last expansion, our By God Alone features rundown covers what it added. Everything else is on our Crusader Kings 3 hub.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many trade goods are in Silk and Silver? 44, in 20 need categories, according to Paradox’s pre-release dev diaries. Sixteen of them are Basic Goods.

What happens if a building’s trade good need is not met? It does not get that need’s bonus, and nothing else happens. The exception is food: a holding that goes hungry loses settlement size and popular opinion until it is fed.

Do trade goods prices follow supply and demand? No. Prices come from each good’s base price, the Market’s Prosperity and modifiers. Scarcity only limits how much you can trade.

Which trade goods cannot be produced in any county? Cheese, cured meat, beer, textiles, leather, glass, jewelry, lacquerware and books. They only come from buildings that convert other goods.

Can landed rulers trade in Silk and Silver? Yes, through Distribution Routes. Dukes and higher can link two Markets in their realm to move Basic Goods between them, with no capacity limit, but they earn no gold. Landed rulers can also commission merchants and collect tolls.

Can you change what a county produces? Yes. Each county has 3 to 5 potential goods, and you can switch its resource district to another one, but you lose the buildings inside it.