Spoiler warning: this post spoils the end of Halifax’s story in Dubious Provenance, a Chapter 3 mission, including the choice you make when you catch him.
Spare Halifax in GTA 6. Killing him counts as violence against a civilian and drags your Criminal Profile toward the violent end, while letting him go keeps it cleaner and still leaves you his stash of cash, jewelry and his car, a ’32 Hustler.
The choice comes at the very end of Dubious Provenance, after a chase, when you have him cornered at gunpoint. Below is how you get there, what each option does, and why sparing him is the better call in Grand Theft Auto VI. If you’d rather not know, our guide to avoiding GTA 6 spoilers is a better read.
How You Get to the Choice
Halifax’s story plays out over several visits. You meet him outside the antique store in Capri, where he offers to appraise the bronze statue and hands over his watch as collateral. Once he has the statue, he stops picking up, and our guide to why Halifax isn’t answering covers that stretch.
After you’ve tracked him down once and he’s asked for more time, he goes quiet again until Evelyn Andrews, the antique dealer, gets in touch. That brings you back to Capri for the last part of the mission. Halifax runs, you chase him down, and when you corner him, the decision is yours: shoot him or let him go.
What Happens If You Kill Halifax
Shooting him is an act of violence against a civilian, and the game counts it against your Criminal Profile, pushing it toward the violent end of the scale. The profile is GTA 6’s running rating of what kind of criminals Jason and Lucia are, on five levels from Professional to Irredeemable, and it changes how the police treat you at the top end. Our guide to how the Criminal Profile works explains every level.
The reward for this part of the mission is his stash, and you don’t need to pull the trigger to get it.
What Happens If You Spare Halifax
Let him go and your profile stays cleaner, and the loot is still yours. His stash holds cash and jewelry, plus his car, a ’32 Hustler, which you can drive off in and keep or sell. You also get the statue back at the end of his story, after everything he put you through to keep it.
To spare him, hold your fire when you have him cornered. If you’re unsure what counts as a clean job, our guide to lowering your Criminal Profile has more on staying at the Professional end.
Our Pick: Spare Him
Sparing Halifax is the better choice for almost everyone:
- It protects your Criminal Profile. A violent stretch can be walked back with cleaner play later, but there’s no reason to add a civilian to the count.
- The loot doesn’t depend on it. You walk away with his stash and the ’32 Hustler after letting him go.
If you’re playing Jason and Lucia as ruthless and don’t care where the profile lands, shooting him is an option, but sparing him already gets you the reward. Our guide to selling cars covers what to do with the Hustler if you don’t want to keep it, and our guide to registering cars explains how to make it yours for good.
Save Before the Chase
Finished missions can’t be replayed in GTA 6, so if you want to see both outcomes, make a manual save before the last part of Dubious Provenance. Our guide to saving in GTA 6 covers the 15 slots, and our Chapter 3 mission list shows where the mission sits in the chapter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you kill or spare Halifax in GTA 6?
Spare him. Killing him counts against your Criminal Profile, and you get his stash after sparing him anyway.
What happens if you kill Halifax?
It counts as violence against a civilian and pushes your Criminal Profile toward the violent end, and sparing him gets you his stash without that cost.
What do you get for sparing Halifax?
His stash of cash and jewelry, his ’32 Hustler, and the statue back.
Where does the kill or spare choice happen?
At the end of Dubious Provenance in Chapter 3, after you chase Halifax down in Capri and corner him.
Does killing Halifax affect your Criminal Profile?
Yes. Shooting him counts as violence against a civilian, so your profile moves toward the violent end.