The best game like Probably Stolen is Papers, Please, the border checkpoint game its creator names as an inspiration, followed by Recettear and Dealer’s Life 2, the two that come closest to its buying, selling and haggling. The 12 others below cover every other part of Questing Goose Studio’s cyberpunk shopkeeping sim, from fake goods and smuggling to climbing debts and life on a lawless space station.
Probably Stolen launched on PC on October 28, and the studio said on November 6 that 1 million shopkeepers had opened the shop. You run a storefront on a dystopian space station where, in the words of its Steam page, “rent is rising, factions are watching, and most of your best margins live in legal gray zones.” We ranked these 15 games on how close each comes to that: strangers at your counter, buying low and selling high, spotting fakes, shady money with the law watching, and a debt that keeps you working. A similar setting breaks ties, and critical reception decides the close calls. Every entry lists the platforms you can buy it on today, checked against Steam, the console stores and the publishers’ own pages on November 8, 2026. Every PS4 game here also runs on PS5, and every Xbox One game on Xbox Series X|S, through backward compatibility. Still running your own shop? Our Probably Stolen hub has every guide, from the best start to making money fast.

15. Nivalis Nights
Platforms: PC (released September 29, 2026).
ION LANDS’ life sim is the pick if the neon is what pulled you in. It is set in Nivalis, the city from the studio’s earlier game Cloudpunk, and it has you “start humble with a noodle stand” before climbing up to restaurants and nightclubs, with the option of “illegally sabotaging your rivals under the cover of curfew.” It is a much slower game than Probably Stolen, since your days go to fishing, decorating apartments and romance as much as to business, and its Steam rating of Mostly Positive is the lowest on this list. Our launch story has the details, and our Cyberpunk hub has more of the setting.

14. TCG Card Shop Simulator
Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch 2 and Nintendo Switch (version 1.0 released September 2026).
Take the crime out of Probably Stolen and you get something like OPNeon Games’ sim: a local game store where you stock shelves, set prices, hire staff and host events. Its Steam page tells you to “keep track of popular trends and adjust your inventory,” and the booster packs add a gamble of their own, since you can crack them open hoping for a rare card to sell. Version 1.0 also made its in-game card game, Tetramon, playable. Probably Stolen launched with bundle discounts for owners of this game, Potion Craft and ReStory: Chill Electronics Repairs, an electronics repair sim from our list of the best cozy games of 2026.

13. Graveyard Keeper
Platforms: PC and Xbox One (released August 15, 2018), PS4 and Nintendo Switch (June 27, 2019), plus iPhone, iPad and Android.
tinyBuild published this one too, and it shares Probably Stolen’s view of capitalism. Lazy Bear Games’ medieval cemetery sim calls itself “a game about the spirit of capitalism, and doing whatever it takes to build a thriving business,” and its Steam page sets the tone: “These dead bodies don’t need all those organs, do they? Why not grind them up and sell them to the local butcher?” There is no counter to work, but the crafting chains and the ethically awful shortcuts are the same kind of fun as cutting a product’s quality on the station. It is on our list of the best cozy spooky games. The sequel, Graveyard Keeper 2, came out on September 22, 2026, and Lazy Bear has already promised fixes for its grind.

12. Space Warlord Organ Trading Simulator
Platforms: PC, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One (released December 7, 2021), and Nintendo Switch (April 29, 2022).
Probably Stolen’s Steam page lists organ dealer among the extra jobs you can master. Strange Scaffold made a whole game out of it. Billed as “the sci-fi body horror market tycoon you didn’t know you needed,” it has you trading in a simulated market of “dozens of commodities” against rival traders while you try to “keep vampire-leech organs from devouring the rest of the goods inside your cargo hold.” It is pure market play with no shop to run, and it moves quickly. If reading prices and managing a cramped inventory is your favorite part of the station, this is that part with the volume turned up.

11. Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator
Platforms: PC (released December 13, 2022), plus PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch.
niceplay games’ alchemist sim, another tinyBuild release, has you make everything you sell. Customers come in every day “looking for solutions to their problems,” and the Steam page promises “consequences depending on what you decide to sell them,” whether you play as “a noble artisan, a greedy weasel, an occult dark master” or anything else. You can haggle with traveling merchants, attract guilds, feud with notable figures and put your own labels on the bottles. It even jokes that “you won’t find a market for a poisonous healing potion… right? Or would you?” It is far gentler than Probably Stolen, which makes it a good cooldown game. It is also on our list of the best cozy spooky games.

10. VA-11 Hall-A: Cyberpunk Bartender Action
Platforms: PC and Linux (released June 21, 2016), PS4 and Nintendo Switch (May 2, 2019).
Sukeban Games swaps the shop counter for a bar in Glitch City, a dystopia where “corporations reign supreme,” but the setup is familiar: strange people sit down in front of you one at a time, and you learn the city through them. You play Jill, a bartender who mixes the drinks her regulars order, and the story branches on what you serve rather than on dialogue choices. Her tips have to cover rent and bills at home, so money is never far from your mind. There is no buying, selling or haggling, so it ranks here for its atmosphere, and few games do cyberpunk at street level this well. Metacritic lists a 77 for the PC version, and its Steam rating is Overwhelmingly Positive.

9. Contraband Police
Platforms: PC (released March 8, 2023), PS5 and Xbox Series X|S (November 7, 2025).
Probably Stolen asks what you can get past Security. Crazy Rocks’ game makes you Security. You are a border inspector in the Acarist People’s Republic in 1981, where “smuggling, corruption and forgery are the order of the day,” checking papers on which “even the slightest discrepancy means refusal of entry,” then searching vehicles with a UV flashlight for hidden goods. The money side will feel familiar too, because foiled smuggling earns cash while the “rising cost of maintaining your station” eats it. It is a much more violent game, with shootouts and car chases, and Metacritic lists a 77 for the PC version.

8. Schedule I
Platforms: PC (Steam early access since March 2025).
If the Chemist start is what hooked you, TVGS’s crime sim is that route as a whole game. You roll into Hyland Point with “no cash, no product and no connections,” produce drugs, discover recipes, hire dealers and buy properties until the whole chain runs itself, all while dealing with “intensifying law enforcement and deadly cartel competitors.” That pressure will be familiar if you have ever had to make Dream Dust for a cartel quota. You walk, skate or drive to your customers instead of waiting behind a counter, and it has online co-op, which Probably Stolen does not. Its Steam rating is Overwhelmingly Positive from more than 200,000 reviews. Our Schedule 1 guides hub covers it, including the best customers for dealers, how to unlock coca seeds and the 100 best Schedule I mods.

7. Moonlighter
Platforms: PC, PS4 and Xbox One (released May 2018), Nintendo Switch (November 5, 2018), plus a Netflix Edition on iPhone and Android.
By day, Digital Sun’s action RPG is a village shop: you put items on sale, “set their price carefully,” recruit assistants and watch out for “shady individuals” who want to steal your stock. By night, you dive into dungeons to find what you will sell tomorrow. Probably Stolen’s night trips to the Dumping Ground are a much smaller version of that loop, as our guide to Junk shows. The combat is half the game, which is why it sits this far down. The sequel, Moonlighter 2: The Endless Vault, left early access on September 2, 2026, and is on PC, PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch 2. Its Steam page promises you can “read your customers to strike the perfect deal.”

6. Citizen Sleeper
Platforms: PC, Mac, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch (released May 5, 2022), PS5 and PS4 (2023).
No game on this list comes closer to living on Probably Stolen’s station. Jump Over The Age’s RPG is set on Erlin’s Eye, “a ruined space station that is home to thousands of people trying to survive on the edges of an interstellar capitalist society,” where you play a digital mind in an artificial body owned by a corporation that wants it back. Each cycle, you spend the dice you are dealt on jobs and favors to earn your keep, and you pick your way between the station’s factions, much as you watch your standing in the Feedback Box back at the shop. It is a text-heavy story game with no store to run, so it ranks below the real shop sims, but Metacritic lists an 82 for the PC version. The sequel, Citizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector, adds a ship and a crew, and Metacritic lists an 85.

5. Strange Antiquities
Platforms: PC, Mac and Nintendo Switch (released September 17, 2025), and PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One (April 30, 2026).
Appraisal is the slow, careful side of Probably Stolen: reading a handbook, checking an item and sending an estimate, then finding out on the appraisal slip how close you were. Bad Viking built a whole game around that feeling. You run a candle-lit shop of occult objects in the town of Undermere, where the job is to “examine, identify and catalogue strange artefacts” using a shelf of illustrated tomes, and the Steam page warns that “mistakes can be… costly.” It also has a mean streak: “Will you help someone with their problem, or curse them with a horrid affliction? In a small town like this, people remember your misdeeds.” It is a puzzle game first, so the tension comes from the mystery rather than the money, and Metacritic lists an 81 for the PC version. Its predecessor, Strange Horticulture, does the same thing with plants.

4. Potionomics
Platforms: PC (released October 17, 2022), plus PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch as Potionomics: Masterwork Edition (October 22, 2024). The PC version got the same content as a free update.
If haggling is your favorite part of Probably Stolen, start here. Voracious Games’ shop sim turns every negotiation into a card battle: you play from a deck to raise the price while managing your stress, and the friends you make around town teach you new tactics. The setup will sound familiar, too. A penniless witch named Sylvia inherits her uncle’s potion shop “and a huge debt,” then has to brew, sell and outdo her rivals to keep it. It is bright and funny, with none of the station’s crime and a dating sim running alongside the business, but no other game makes the moment you name your price this tense. Its Steam rating is Very Positive.

3. Dealer’s Life 2
Platforms: PC (released February 15, 2022), plus iPhone, iPad and Android.
When Questing Goose Studio first announced Probably Stolen, it called it “a cyberpunk pawnshop simulator.” This is the pawn shop part on its own. Abyte Entertainment’s tycoon starts you in a rundown shack, sends a stream of strange customers through your door, and asks you to read each one as you negotiate. It also has the threat that makes Probably Stolen’s counter tense: “Scammers will try to take advantage of you with counterfeit items and contracts, hoping you have no clue of the real value of the item you want to sell or buy.” As you grow, you add employees, auctions and investments, the same climb as upgrading the shop on the station. It is goofier and much smaller than Probably Stolen, with no station politics to navigate, and its Steam rating of Very Positive comes from only about 300 reviews, but nothing else on this list is so purely about the deal. Abyte’s newer Dealer’s Life Legend (July 2025) moves the same idea to a traveling merchant in the Pecunian Empire.

2. Recettear: An Item Shop’s Tale
Platforms: PC (on Steam since October 2010).
The oldest game on this list is still the cleanest version of Probably Stolen’s money pressure. EasyGameStation’s RPG, localized by Carpe Fulgur, stars Recette, whose father skips out on a loan and leaves a fairy named Tear to collect. The payments climb, and, as the Steam page puts it, “if you can’t come up with the money… well, hope you like living in a cardboard box.” You stock up from the markets in town or from customers who bring goods to your counter, then haggle over every sale, knowing a buyer walks if you push too hard. Prices shift with news events and trends, so timing matters just as it does in a station shortage. The way out is the same as well: earn enough to be free of the debt, the way buying the store ends rent for good.
It is a cheerful anime game rather than a grimy one, and you also go dungeon crawling with hired adventurers for free stock. But as a game about buying low, selling high and dreading the next payment, it has aged very well. Metacritic lists an 82, and its Steam rating is Overwhelmingly Positive.

1. Papers, Please
Platforms: PC, Mac and Linux (released August 2013), plus iPhone, iPad and Android.
The best game like Probably Stolen is the one its creator named. When the studio announced the game, it said the biggest inspirations of Bei Ning Pan, who began it as a solo project, were Space Station 13 “and also a bit of Papers, Please.” Lucas Pope’s 2013 game makes you an immigration inspector at a border checkpoint in the communist state of Arstotzka, checking documents at a booth while “hidden smugglers, spies, and terrorists” try to slip through. Hunting for a mismatch in a passport is the same skill as checking a seller’s goods for flaws or going through the signs when you identify an Aug.
The pressure is the same as well. You are paid per person you process, you can take bribes at your own risk, and at the end of each day you decide whether your wages cover rent, food and heat for your family. Run out of money and it is over. A group called EZIC comes to your booth with its own plans for the government, and what you do for it and everyone else leads to one of 20 endings. You cannot buy, sell or haggle, which is why Recettear and Dealer’s Life 2 are closer if trading is the draw. But no other game captures so well the feeling that the next stranger at your counter could ruin you. Metacritic lists an 85 for the PC version, and its Steam rating is Overwhelmingly Positive from about 40,000 reviews.
Why Space Station 13 Is Not on the List
Bei Ning Pan’s other inspiration is the older and stranger of the two. Space Station 13 is a multiplayer sandbox in which crews on corporate-owned space stations try to keep the place running and stay alive, in roles from staff assistant to engineer to captain, while antagonists such as nuclear operatives and aliens try to wreck it all. It is completely free, according to its official site, and worth a look if you want to see what inspired Probably Stolen. We left it unranked because it plays nothing like a shop sim: it is a round-based game for crowds of players, and it has no store page to check it against.
Games Like Probably Stolen by Platform
Probably Stolen itself is only on PC for now, and Valve rates it Playable on Steam Deck. These are the options elsewhere:
- PS5: Potionomics: Masterwork Edition, Strange Antiquities, Citizen Sleeper, Contraband Police, Potion Craft and TCG Card Shop Simulator have PS5 versions, and Moonlighter, VA-11 Hall-A and Graveyard Keeper run on PS5 through backward compatibility.
- Xbox: Potionomics: Masterwork Edition, Strange Antiquities, Citizen Sleeper, Contraband Police, Potion Craft, Space Warlord Organ Trading Simulator and TCG Card Shop Simulator have Xbox Series X|S versions, and Moonlighter and Graveyard Keeper run on them through backward compatibility.
- Nintendo Switch: Potionomics: Masterwork Edition, Strange Antiquities, Citizen Sleeper, Moonlighter, VA-11 Hall-A, Potion Craft, Space Warlord Organ Trading Simulator, Graveyard Keeper and TCG Card Shop Simulator, which also has a Switch 2 version.
- PC: every game on this list.
- iPhone and Android: Papers, Please, Dealer’s Life 2 and Graveyard Keeper, plus Moonlighter’s Netflix Edition.
Upcoming Games Like Probably Stolen
- Ghost Receipt: A Cyberpunk Pawnshop Simulator (Steam lists November 10, 2026): the closest match on paper, from Kistler Studios. You run a pawn shop in the neon city of Neo Haven, where you “inspect mysterious items, question suspicious sellers, uncover hidden value, and spot counterfeits.” There is a free demo on Steam.
- Black Market INC. (Steam lists November 12, 2026, in early access): a first-person sandbox from Pixellow Official about running a criminal empire, in which you “produce illegal goods, automate production, hire staff, complete customer orders.”
- Space Station 14 (Steam says “Coming soon”): the free, open source remake of Space Station 13, which its official site says you can already play through its own launcher.
One brand-new game is too new to rank. Black Market Space Station Shop Simulator, a $4.99 text-based trading game from Dragon Dropper, launched on Steam on October 27, 2026, and has you running a space station’s general store on parole after a smuggling sentence. The premise is close, but it had no user reviews on Steam when we checked.
Or you can stay on the station: the roadmap adds a free Junker Update in December and major updates in January and April 2027, and our guide to the ending explains what happens once you get that far.
Frequently Asked Questions
What game is Probably Stolen most like? Papers, Please is the closest for its tension at the counter, its spot-the-fake checks and its dystopian setting, and the studio has named it as an inspiration. For the trading itself, Recettear and Dealer’s Life 2 are closer, because Papers, Please has no buying or selling.
What inspired Probably Stolen? Questing Goose Studio’s announcement says developer Bei Ning Pan’s biggest inspirations were Space Station 13 “and also a bit of Papers, Please.”
Are there games like Probably Stolen on PS5, Xbox, or Switch? Yes. Potionomics: Masterwork Edition, Strange Antiquities, Citizen Sleeper and TCG Card Shop Simulator are all on PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Nintendo Switch. Probably Stolen itself is only on PC for now.
Is there a cyberpunk game like Probably Stolen? VA-11 Hall-A is the closest cyberpunk game at a counter, Citizen Sleeper is the closest space station, and Nivalis Nights is the closest cyberpunk business sim. Ghost Receipt, a cyberpunk pawn shop sim, is listed on Steam for November 10, 2026.
Is there a co-op game like Probably Stolen? Schedule I has online co-op and the closest crime business loop. Probably Stolen is single-player only.
Is there a free game like Probably Stolen? Space Station 13, one of its inspirations, is free, though it is a multiplayer sandbox and not a shop sim. Its remake, Space Station 14, is free too. Every game on our ranked list is paid.
What are the upcoming games like Probably Stolen? Ghost Receipt is listed on Steam for November 10, 2026, and Black Market INC. for November 12, 2026, in early access. Space Station 14’s Steam page says “Coming soon.”