How To Video Game

GTA 6: What Happens If You Spare Arnold (SPOILERS)

Stacks of cash, a duffel bag and two patterned guns on the back seat of a car at night in GTA 6

Spoiler warning: this guide covers the choice at the end of Hey Arnold!, a Chapter 1 story mission, and hints at a payoff later in the story without describing it.

If you spare Arnold in GTA 6, he swims away and lives, and he turns up again later in the story for a moment you only get if you let him go. Kill him instead and he’s gone for good, so you lose that later scene.

We spared Arnold on our PS5 copy of Grand Theft Auto VI, and the choice itself, plus what came right after, comes from our own recording. We won’t say what the later payoff is, since it’s worth seeing for yourself. If you’d like to keep the rest of the story fresh, our guide to avoiding GTA 6 spoilers has some tips.

How the Choice Works

Hey Arnold! ends on a dock. After the meeting at the radar station falls apart and you chase Arnold down, Jason ends up holding him at gunpoint while he kneels at the water’s edge. The objective reads “Choose what to do with Arnold,” and a Spare prompt appears at the bottom right.

  • To spare him, press Cross at the Spare prompt.
  • To kill him, pull the trigger instead. Jason’s aim stays locked on Arnold, and the prompt names him beside the L2 icon.

Think it over before you press anything, because there’s no undoing it. Our Hey Arnold! walkthrough covers the whole mission up to this point.

What Happens When You Spare Arnold

In our game, Arnold thanked Jason, said “I’m just gonna swim away,” and ran for the end of the dock. As he swam off, Jason called after him: “Hey, Arnold? Remember what I said.”

The scene then cut to Brian’s place. When Brian asked whether Jason had taken care of “that thing,” Jason kept it vague: “Yeah, Arnold’s gonna keep his mouth shut.” Brian took that as a job done.

The bigger effect comes much later. A spared Arnold isn’t written out of the story: he can show up again in a later mission, in a scene that doesn’t happen if he’s dead. That makes sparing him the choice with something extra attached, while killing him closes his story on the dock.

Shortly after, back at the house, Brian texted Jason: “One more thing, left your pay for those packages and that Mandy and Arnold business in your mailbox.” Our guide to Jason’s mailbox shows where to collect it.

Spare or Kill: Which Should You Pick?

Spare him. Letting Arnold go keeps a later moment in the story, and it’s also the cleaner pick for your Criminal Profile, GTA 6’s running read on what kind of criminals Jason and Lucia are. Killing pushes that profile toward the violent end of the scale, while sparing people keeps it cleaner. Our guide to the Criminal Profile explains how it’s built up.

Killing him only makes sense if you’re deliberately playing Jason as ruthless and don’t mind missing the later scene.

If You Already Killed Him

Finished missions can’t be replayed in GTA 6, so there’s no going back to change your mind from the mission menu. If you have a manual save from before Hey Arnold!, loading it is the only way to make the other choice. Our guides to saving in GTA 6 and replaying missions explain how to keep a backup for big decisions like this.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you spare Arnold in GTA 6?

Yes. Sparing him keeps him alive for a moment later in the story, and it’s the cleaner choice for your Criminal Profile.

Does Arnold come back in GTA 6?

He can, if you spare him. A spared Arnold turns up again later in the story, while a dead one is gone for good.

How do you spare Arnold?

At the end of Hey Arnold!, press Cross at the Spare prompt while Jason holds him at gunpoint on the dock.

What happens if you kill Arnold?

Arnold’s story ends on the dock, and you miss the later scene that sparing him leads to. It also counts against your Criminal Profile.

More GTA