The best choice in GTA 6’s Dubious Provenance is to give Halifax the statue. Rejecting him doesn’t send the mission anywhere new: it only puts it on hold, and you have to go back to Capri and hand the statue over anyway before the story can carry on.
We chose Reject on our PS5 copy of Grand Theft Auto VI to see what it does, and the details below come from our own recording. Here’s how the mission brings you to the choice, what Give and Reject each do in the moment, and why giving it straight away saves you a trip. We stop short of what Halifax does next, which is a story spoiler.
How the Choice Comes Up
Dubious Provenance is the fourth story mission of Chapter 3 in our full mission list. Here’s the first stretch, up to the choice:
- Pick up the statue. After Cal’s visit to the Bayside apartment, an icon appears at the closet door. Interact with it to start the mission.
- Drive to Capri. The card reads “Collect the statue and take it to the antique store in Capri to get it valued accurately.” Capri is on the west coast, a long drive from Vice City.
- Go to the antique store. Evelyn Andrews Antiques and Collectibles is on the corner of South Cunningham Drive and East Buckley Drive, in the middle of town.
- Talk to Evelyn. She won’t value it or buy it, and tells you it’s “either a very good fake, or it is stolen.”
- Meet Halifax outside. He offers to have the statue appraised and puts up his watch, a 1972 “Crowex Chronograph,” as collateral. He ends with “The choice is yours,” and the prompt appears: Give on Cross, Reject on Square.
Our guide to where to find Halifax has screenshots of the route and the store.
What Happens If You Choose Give
Halifax takes the statue to be appraised and you keep his watch as collateral while he has it. The mission carries on from there, and the parts that follow are where its rewards are.
What Halifax does once the statue is in his hands is a story spoiler, so we’ve kept it out of this guide. If you want to know, our guides to why Halifax isn’t answering and whether to kill or spare Halifax cover it, both with spoilers.
What Happens If You Choose Reject
You keep the statue for now, and nothing else changes. When we turned him down, the answer was “Thanks, but… we’ll hold onto it for now,” and Halifax replied, “Up to you, let me know if you change your mind.”
A little later he started a group chat with Jason and Lucia: “Thanks for dropping by! If you change your mind, just give me a call. B. Halifax.” It offered two replies, “Thanks, we’ll think about it” and “We’re not interested.” The game then let us drive off and get on with other things.
To pick the mission back up, call Halifax from your phone’s contacts (press Up on the D-pad for the phone), then go back to Capri and give him the statue. Our guide to calling Jason and Lucia covers the phone basics.
Why Give Is the Best Choice
- The outcome is the same either way. Rejecting doesn’t open a different path or let you keep the statue for good. It only delays the moment you hand it over.
- It saves a long drive. Capri is a trek from Vice City, and saying no means making that trip a second time.
- The rewards come later. The rest of Dubious Provenance only opens once Halifax has the statue, so giving it up is how you reach the payoff.
The only reason to reject him is if you want to keep playing other missions first. That’s fine: his text stays in your phone, and you can call him whenever you’re ready.
What the Statue Is Worth
Nobody in the game puts a price on it. Jason guesses on the drive that bronze statues like it can go for ten grand or more, Evelyn won’t touch it, and Halifax calls it “extremely valuable.” Our guide to what the bronze statue is worth goes through what each of them says, and our Chapter 3 mission list shows where Dubious Provenance falls in the chapter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you give or reject the statue in Dubious Provenance?
Give it to Halifax. Rejecting only delays the mission, because you have to go back and give it to him before the story carries on.
What does Reject do in Dubious Provenance?
You keep the statue for now, and Halifax texts you to call him if you change your mind. Nothing else changes.
Can you keep the statue in GTA 6?
Not for good. To finish Dubious Provenance, you have to hand it over to Halifax.
What do you get for giving Halifax the statue?
His watch, a 1972 Crowex Chronograph, as collateral while he has it appraised. The rest of the mission follows from there.
What buttons are Give and Reject?
On PS5, Give is Cross and Reject is Square.